This list was organized and voted on by Sarasota / Bradenton area coaches, then provided to Tampa Lax Report to publish.
All-Area
| Out-of-Door | Emma Bonacuse |
| Out-of-Door | Aubrey Robbins |
| Out-of-Door | Dani Taraska |
| Riverview | Kate Fleming |
| Riverview | Susan Lowther |
| Riverview | Caroline Steinwachs |
| Venice | Sophia Santagata |
| IMG | Erin Berls |
| Manatee | Grace Knowles |
| Manatee | Penelope May |
| St. Stephen’s | Sienna Cassella |
| St. Stephen’s | Ashing Marshall |
1st Team
| Out-of-Door | Emma Arrigo |
| Out-of-Door | Megan Dowdell |
| Riverview | Clara Keyvani |
| Riverview | Mia Rey |
| St. Stephen’s | Bella Rosa |
| St. Stephen’s | Annesley Flint |
| Manatee | Sydney Morrison |
| Venice | Kaya Bartlett |
| Lakewood Ranch | Joslyn Chapman |
| Sarasota | Ava Kozicky |
| Cardinal Mooney | Morgan Cosallos |
| IMG | Ruby Lynch |
Honorable Mention
| Out-of-Door | Cristia Harold |
| Out-of-Door | Ainsley Smith |
| Riverview | Chloe Jarman |
| Riverview | Chloe Hackl |
| St. Stephen’s | Haley Rosa |
| St. Stephen’s | Sophia Creneti |
| Manatee | Abby Clark |
| Manatee | Cara Carter |
| Venice | Gianna Falbo |
| Venice | Willow O’Toole |
| Lakewood Ranch | Morgan McCabe |
| Lakewood Ranch | Brooke Harris |
| IMG | Nathasha Newport |
| IMG | Ava Kitt |
| Sarasota | Veronika Chalupa |
| Sarasota | Katie Armstrong |
| Cardinal Mooney | Darling Bergstrom |
| Cardinal Mooney | Lauren Consiglio |
| Bradenton Christian | Juliana Bartz |
| Bradenton Christian | Leah Grace Young |
| Sarasota Military | Eva Nazario |
| Sarasota Military | Anastasia Decker |
All-District
| Riverview | Kate Fleming |
| Riverview | Susan Lowther |
| Riverview | Caroline Steinwachs |
| Riverview | Mia Rey |
| Manatee | Grace Knowles |
| Manatee | Penelope May |
| Manatee | Cara Carter |
| Manatee | Sydney Morrison |
| Lakewood Ranch | Joslyn Chapman |
| Lakewood Ranch | Brooke Harris |
| Sarasota | Ava Kozicky |
| Sarasota | Veronika Chalupa |
