All-American
| Taylor Lapointe | 2023 | Midfield | Steinbrenner |
| Lane Calkins | 2022 | Midfield | Naples |
| Abigale Eash | 2023 | Goalie | Steinbrenner |
| Samantha Swanovich | 2022 | Midfield | Newsome |
| Kali Cleary | 2024 | Midfield | Gulf Coast |
| Susan Lowther | 2024 | Midfield | Riverview |
| Ruby Lynch | 2023 | Midfield | IMG |
| Sienna Casella | 2024 | Midfield | St. Stephen’s Episcopal School |
| Ashley Quinn | 2022 | Midfield | Berkeley Prep |
| Emma Smith | 2023 | Attack | Community School of Naples |
All-Academic
| Kaitlin Price | 2023 | Midfield | Steinbrenner |
| Maya Bronson | 2022 | Midfield | Newsome |
| Sophia Pyne | 2022 | Midfield | Academy of the Holy Names |
| Katie Lind | 2023 | Defense | Steinbrenner |
| Finley Jordan | 2023 | Defense | Berkeley Prep |
| Sophia Creneti | 2023 | Defense | St. Stephen’s Episcopal School |
| Anna Castro | 2023 | Defense | H.B. Plant |
| Elena Hangen | 2023 | Attack | Sickles |
| Sophia Gray | 2023 | Attack | H.B. Plant |
| Bella Rosa | 2023 | Attack | St. Stephen’s Episcopal School |
Jackie Pitts Award
| Kela Watts | 2022 | Attack | Robinson |
